If Guitar is a Means to an End, What Are Some Ends?

Before reading this blog post, remember that it is not unusual to gravitate to one of these motivations a bit more than any others. This is not "black and white" so-to-speak. We all want to learn, have fun, feel creative, and connect with others. However, each of us has a bit more compelling of a reason to do it. The following is a summary of four of the most common motivations all of us, including me, have when we pick up the guitar and decide to learn it.

Fun and Enjoyment.

Enjoyment? That's probably the number one reason why people play it and want to learn it. If it looks fun and enjoyable, then why not?

Connection.

Connection. There are people out there who feel that the most important reason to play guitar is to connect with others. I am reminded of a colleague in grad school. Her mother always held her as a baby and played guitar at the same time. The result is that she formed a sort of association of connection with the instrument. For her, seeing a guitarist live meant she could feel that connection. Getting together and playing music with other people is a fantastic way to just hang out too. Musicians love to hang.

Creativity.

There are people out there who look to guitar as an avenue to create. The tell-tale signs? Time passing by and enjoyment of finding and exploring the capabilities of the guitar. Pushing the sound. Recording musical thoughts. The person who is obsessed with creating music just wants to find the ways that work for them with guitar, and educational tradition is playfully tossed out in the pursuit.

Intellectual Stimulation.

There are many people out there who love to learn. However, there are people who like to know the nuts and bolts of music and want to know what it's all about to a large extent. Learning guitar, for these people, is often guided with an intense curiosity with regards to music theory and/or scales. For these people, guitar is a lovely way to grow and expand their thinking abilities, and look cool at the same time when they play... of course!

Posted by Dave Wirth
 

Guitar is Supposed to Be Fun

Guitar is fun. I want to make sure that this message comes loud and clear to everyone who reads this blog.

There are thousands of guitar teachers who unwittingly set obstacles in the way of students who just wants to learn and enjoy the guitar. Sure, some students really respond well to learning from these obstacles, but every single one? I doubt it. If a student hates the idea of learning music theory, chances are they could have a different idea of what they want to do with guitar than the teacher think is possible (like, as a chance to be creative). If a student really has no interest in learning scales, chances are that a teacher who forces the issue will lose them eventually.

I really like to go on rants about music theory and scales. I know both inside and out, and yet I don't teach them to everyone. To me, they are the most mis-used pedagogical concepts in music education. No one seems to be questioning why they are good, but it seems like too many people are blindly saying that "every student must learn music theory regardless of their interest in it." 

This is wrong, and you have a right to question it if your teacher is making you learn it.

To the people who are playing guitar and are being told that they must learn something they don't want to, I hope you feel free enough to question your teacher's authority. If they are worth their salt, they will explain why it's important and in a kind way. They won't get flustered, and they will appreciate your view, immensely. What if the teacher gets angry? What if he or she takes offence to you asking questions? Avoid them. They are not worth your time. They are providing barriers to enjoyment of guitar, not making it more possible and within your reach.

In order for guitar to be fun, you need to find others who think of guitar as an incredibly fun way to pass the time. This goes for both teachers and people we meet to jam with. We all have different reasons to play, but if it's not fun, why do it?

Posted by Dave Wirth